True. Also, I dont feel the poptop was unfair. I feel that if you decide to add the poptop you already came up with the solution. you just need to display it to everybody what the poptop decided to do. This game is fun, balanced, and able to turn everything on its head.
I would not actually do it I have successfully helped kill a community for about a month by hosting a game with that Plus it's a horrid mess to keep track of
Killing a community, or the game? Because yes I'm the only person so far that I've found that's crazy enough to actually try running a game with healthbars and mana
Do health or mana Don't do both Trust me, you will regret it Especially if you get a DragonKing in your game He will somehow find a way to break it
@Zebe you could "fix" poptop by editing the message sent to say "please do not discuss the contents of this message in the thread "
On the other side of the equation, what if there's an Arsonist, or some other role which orients itself on maximum secrecy? Oh my gosh between him and Taboo I swear But I made the mistake of giving Dragon the only role in the game that could generate MP You can see where that went...
Then the Poptop can go to a corner and think what it has just done to its only teammate. Arsonist's presence being revealed at least will be Poptop's fault, instead of a broken role revealing Arsonist's identity.
Maybe instead of being super specific, it can reveal that poptop joined either town, mafia, or "a neutral"? Still gives info but doesn't make poptop stay away from choices like arso or Agaran.
@FranticLibra's game, Praise the Sun, has it's signups open. Join now! http://community.playstarbound.com/threads/135433/