I think he was referring to the whole "it's not bad design. It's different design" thing in your post. I get where you're coming from; We all have different perspectives, but I think the real value in discussion comes from saying what you personally like/dislike instead of "this is different." Also gives devs more to work with. If an engineer gave someone two flashlights and the person said "These flashlights are different." That doesn't really help drive change. And I know that's not all you did though. You added your own opinions in there which is good. The whole fence sitting thing just bugs me sometimes.